In the second week of December 2025, 143 Pinnacle Road in Ocean City changed hands for $3.5 million. The same week, 901 St. James Place recorded at $2.775 million, 2622 Wesley Avenue at $2.4 million and 50 Wesley Road at $2.249 million. The Cape May County Herald's property transfer chart for Dec. 8 to 14, 2025 counted 15 Ocean City transfers worth $22.07 million that week, with a median of $1,198,000. Over the New Year's week of Dec. 29, 2025 to Jan. 4, 2026, Ocean City again led every municipality in the county. It recorded $10,079,811 in transfers, about 21 percent of the county total, including $2.2 million for 3708 Westminster Ln and $1,999,000 for 713 Second St, according to the Herald's chart for that week.
Those were the weeks of mid-December and New Year's, and none of it looks like a clearance sale. Still, the advice repeated every November is that winter is when buyers win on price. OCNJ Daily's November 2025 guide to timing a purchase called December through February the slowest stretch, with "minimal inventory and fewer buyers," and said winter buyers "can often secure properties at the lowest prices of the annual cycle."
Last winter's county numbers back up the thin inventory and do not show the lower prices. When the off-season arrives, sellers leave the market about as fast as buyers do, so the share of asking price that sellers collect barely moves. A winter buyer gets something real, and it is not a discount.
The County Numbers From Last Winter
The cleanest public monthly data for this market comes from New Jersey Realtors' Local Market Updates. These are county reports. New Jersey Realtors makes municipal reports available only to members, so every figure below describes Cape May County as a whole, and Ocean City is one large piece of it. Medians in particular shift with whichever towns and price points closed that month. We covered that problem in why no two websites agree on Ocean City's median home price. The measure that matters here is the percent of list price received, which is less affected by that mix.
| Month, Cape May County | Single-family: % of list received | Single-family: months of supply | Condo/townhouse: % of list received |
|---|---|---|---|
| November 2025 | 96.8% | 3.5 | 97.6% |
| December 2025 | 96.9% | 3.0 | 97.8% |
| January 2026 | 96.5% | 3.0 | 98.0% |
| February 2026 | 97.0% | 3.2 | 98.4% |
| May 2026 | 98.8% | 4.0 | 98.1% |
| July 2026 | 97.1% | 3.9 | 97.6% |
| October 2026 | 97.0% | 4.4 | 97.9% |
A single-family seller in Cape May County got 96.5 percent of list in January 2026, the weakest month on the chart. That is less than half a point below the 97.1 percent sellers got in July 2026, at the height of the season. Condos went the other way. Condo sellers did better in February 2026, at 98.4 percent of list, than in any of the spring or summer months shown.
February is the deepest-winter month on the chart, and February 2026 sales still closed at 97.0 percent of asking for single-family homes and 98.4 percent for condos.
Why Winter Is the Tightest Stretch of the Year
The months-of-supply column explains the steady prices. Months of supply measures how long the current inventory would last at the recent pace of sales, and it is the clearest single read on who has the upper hand. Last winter it fell to 3.0 months for single-family homes in December 2025 and January 2026, the lowest point on the chart. By comparison, October 2025 stood at 3.8 months and October 2026 stands at 4.4.
Measured that way, the market got tighter in winter. Only 71 new single-family listings came on in December 2025, and 58 new condo listings, while 121 single-family sales closed that month. Single-family inventory fell from 447 homes in November to 381 in December. It bottomed at 378 in January, against 459 in July 2026.
OCNJ Daily's reasoning was that the sellers left in winter tend to be motivated ones. That may be true of any one house. But the sellers who are not in a hurry are the ones who leave, and in a second-home market many owners have no reason to list a shore house in December. They wait for spring, so the homes still for sale in January are fewer, and the buyers chasing them did not have to compete for them at a discount.
Days on market rose a little. Single-family homes that sold in January 2026 spent an average of 75 days on the market until sale, against 60 in July 2026. The slower pace shows up in time, not in price, and time is the real advantage a winter buyer has.
Spring Starts in February
People who plan to wait for the spring market tend to picture April. Last year, the listings started arriving well before that. Single-family new listings went from 71 in December 2025 to 124 in January and 135 in February. Condo new listings went from 58 to 138 and then 154. February's 154 new condo listings came within four of May 2026's 158.
That moves the real deadline earlier. A buyer who wants first look at the homes owners have been holding back since fall needs financing, a short list of blocks and a sense of value settled by late January. That buyer is not shopping in winter for a bargain. They are getting ready for the listings that arrive while the beaches are still empty.
Ocean City's summer showed what happens to anyone who waits for peak season instead. OCNJ Local reported in July 2026 that the expected wave of summer listings never came, that available homes stayed "exceptionally scarce," and that the island recorded its two highest-priced residential sales ever within the same seven days. The outlet tied the shortage to owners holding onto low mortgage rates from years past.
This Winter Starts With More Homes for Sale
This is where this year differs from last, and why the month after Thanksgiving deserves a closer look than usual. Cape May County entered November 2026 with more homes for sale and fewer closings than a year earlier. In October 2026, the county had 493 single-family homes for sale, compared with 483 in October 2025, and months of supply rose from 3.8 to 4.4. Single-family closed sales fell 22.6 percent from October 2025, to 127, and year-to-date closings through October were down 11.3 percent. Condo and townhouse inventory stood at 523 in October 2026, up 5.0 percent, with 4.8 months of supply.
Prices have not slipped. October 2026 single-family sellers still got 97.0 percent of list, and the county's single-family median that month was $950,000, up 16.9 percent from October 2025. Even so, the starting point is looser than last year. Last winter, supply dropped from 3.8 months in October to 3.0 by December. If the same seasonal pullback happens this year, starting from 4.4 months, December 2026 would still be roomier than December 2025, giving a buyer more homes to compare this winter than last.
If Ocean City follows the county, more homes that sat through the fall will still be on the market after Thanksgiving. A listing that stays up through the holidays is a better reason to make a careful offer than the old idea that everything gets cheaper in December.
What a Winter Buyer Actually Gains
None of what last winter offered a buyer was a lower price per dollar of asking. A slower pace, with January's 75-day average against July's 60, gives more room to see a house twice and bring back a contractor. Winter also shows a house at its worst, and OCNJ Daily's guide pointed out that winter shows how the heating system and insulation perform, and that inspectors and closing professionals have more room in their schedules. Then there is the calendar, since a contract signed in December or January can close in time to furnish the house before Memorial Day.
The Herald's December chart shows the kind of property that still changed hands in those weeks: homes on Wesley Avenue and Wesley Road, a $3.5 million sale on Pinnacle Road, and a $2,499,999 mixed-use or multi-parcel property at 900-908 Bay Avenue.
A Few Questions Buyers Ask
Are these Ocean City figures or county figures? The monthly sale-to-list, inventory and supply figures cover all of Cape May County, because municipal reports are not public. The Ocean City figures in this post come from the Cape May County Herald's weekly charts of recorded transfers. The Herald noted that some of those entries were fractional or partial-interest transfers, so they are not a clean count of home sales.
Do condos follow the same pattern as houses? Condos held up even better last winter. The county's condo and townhouse sale-to-list ratio rose every month from November 2025 through February 2026, from 97.6 percent to 98.4 percent.
When should a winter buyer be ready to write an offer? Ideally before February, which is when new listings jumped last year. Our buyer's guide covers getting ready, and the Ocean City neighborhood pages can help narrow the search to particular blocks.
If you want to know which Ocean City homes are still listed after Thanksgiving, and how this December's supply compares with last year's, The Anchor Group can walk you through what is on the market now, block by block. Start your shore search with us now, and you will be ready when the February listings arrive.